AJLS - Ilmu Hukum & Hak Asasi Manusia

RECONSTRUCTING THE REGIONAL LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT MECHANISM OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL BUDGET (APBD) IN NORTH SUMATRA: A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE ON LIABILITY AND COMPENSATION

Muhammad Rahmaddian Syah
ZenodoDOI
Volume & IsuVol. 1, No. 1
ISSN-

Abstrak

This study investigates the legal mechanisms and institutional effectiveness of regional legislative (DPRD) oversight over the implementation of the Regional Budget (APBD) in North Sumatra from a civil law perspective, focusing on legal liability and restitution/compensation frameworks.

Kata Kunci

Legislative OversightAPBDCivil LiabilityNorth SumatraCompensation Mechanism

Pembaca Naskah Digital

Watermark

Memuat Halaman 1...

AT-RQS Official Logo

APASIFIC RESEARCH QUALITY PROFILE™

OFFICIAL AT-RQS™ v1.0

Tri-Source Research Quality Assessment • APS-AT-RQS-243af6f2-v1.0

Research Quality Score
79.1/ 100
GOOD RESEARCH QUALITY
Scale 0.0–10.0: 7.91 / 10
Evidence Consistency (AECI™)
94/ 100
High Structural Alignment
Evidence Coverage: 5 / 5 Elements (100%)
Assessment Confidence (AAC™)
86%
Tri-Source Consensus
ARTI™ Agreement Index: 91 / 100

Tri-Source Layer Contribution

ARTI™ Triangulation: 91
Layer 1: CLUE (Evidence & Limits)90
Layer 2: SCREEN (Risk & Novelty)72
Layer 3: SCORE (Quality Rubric)79

8 APASIFIC Research Quality Dimensions

Methodology-Weighted Model + Confidence Meta-Dimension
A — Academic Contribution
73 / 100
Novelty & Research Gap Rigor
P — Procedural Rigor
75 / 100
Sampling & Methodology Design
A — Analytical Strength
84 / 100
Statistical Power & Model Fit
S — Scholarly Communication
77 / 100
Structure, Clarity & Citations
I — Integrity & Transparency
84 / 100
Documented Limitations Openness
F — Future Research Value
82 / 100
Follow-up Agenda & Gap Potential
I — Impact & Applicability
87 / 100
Practical & Policy Utility
C — Confidence AssessmentMeta • Non-Weighted
86 / 100
Tri-source agreement, evidence completeness & assessment reliability
Research Strengths

🟢 Primary: Strong analytical evidence and robust statistical methodology

🟢 Secondary: Practical utility and direct organizational/policy applicability

Documented Limitations

🟡 Single-institution population context with cross-sectional observation scope.

This score is an assessment indicator, not a certification of research validity, originality, or scientific truth.
APASIFIC Academic Registry • Immutable Record

ASIA INDEX RECORD

VERIFIED & INDEXED

Official Scholarly Passport & Academic Identity Record · ASIA Index International Database

View ASIA Index Record

1. Record Information

Record FieldOfficial Record Value
ASIA Index Record IDASIA-2026-702291
Index StatusVERIFIED & INDEXED
Record TypeScholarly Article
Publication OriginAPASIFIC Scholarly Ecosystem
Date Submit23 Agustus 2026
Date Published23 Agustus 2026
Record Version1.0 (Canonical Release)

2. Article Identification

FieldDetails
Article TitleRECONSTRUCTING THE REGIONAL LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT MECHANISM OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL BUDGET (APBD) IN NORTH SUMATRA: A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE ON LIABILITY AND COMPENSATION
DOI10.5281/zenodo.22065339
Publication Venue / JournalAJLS - Ilmu Hukum & Hak Asasi Manusia
ISSN / eISSNDalam Antrean
Subject CategoryLegal & Social Studies
Document Type / LanguageResearch Article · English

3. Author & Research Identity

Identity ElementVerification Details
AuthorsMuhammad Rahmaddian Syah
ORCID Registry✓ Linked / Verified System ID
AffiliationsAcademic & Research Institution
Author Identity Status✓ Verified & Provenance Resolved

4. Scholarly Infrastructure & Indexing Chain

Provenance Score: 90 / 100
Source / InfrastructureStatusRecord / Evidence
APASIFIC(30/30 pts)
✓ Origin VerifiedInternal Publication Record
DOI / Zenodo(25/25 pts)
✓ Verified10.5281/zenodo.22065339
Zenodo(15/15 pts)
✓ LinkedZenodo ID: 0
OpenAIRE(15/15 pts)
✓ DiscoveredEuropean Research Graph Record
ORCID(0/10 pts)
LinkedAuthor Research Identity
Google Scholar(5/5 pts)
✓ DiscoverableScholarly Discovery & Citation Observation

5. ASIA Article Metrics (Individual)

Article Level
Article MetricValue
Total CitationsNon-Self: 0 · Author Self: 0 · Journal Self: 00
ASIA Article Score (AAS)72
Citation Velocity1.2 / Year
Citation Network StatusVerified Citation Graph
Scholarly Chain Score90 / 100
Metric StatusACTIVE

6. Journal-Level ASIA Metrics

Prestige Rank
Journal MetricValue
ASIA Citation Score (ACS)Corpus Network Density: 0.01588.42
ASIA Scholarly Rank (ASR)Prestige-weighted Network Metric1.873
ASIA Impact Factor (AIF)2.64
ASIA Percentile91th Percentile
ASIA Metric QuartileAM-Q1
Category Rank9 / 100

7. Record Verification Layer

Metadata✓ Verified
DOI Resolution✓ Verified
Provenance90/100 Verified
Duplicates✓ Passed
Citation Data✓ Active
ASIA IntegrityVERIFIED

This record represents the indexed scholarly identity, publication provenance, metadata connectivity, and metric status of this article within the ASIA Index ecosystem.

ASIA-CANONICAL-RECORD

Sampul Depan (Cover)

Cover RECONSTRUCTING THE REGIONAL LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT MECHANISM OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL BUDGET (APBD) IN NORTH SUMATRA: A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE ON LIABILITY AND COMPENSATION
AJLS
RECONSTRUCTING THE REGIONAL LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT MECHANISM OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL BUDGET (APBD) IN NORTH SUMATRA:A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE ON LIABILITY AND COMPENSATION

DOI

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22065339

VOL 1

EDISI 1

AUG

2026

📊

Artikel Score

Evaluasi Kualitas Naskah Akademik

Official Record
Overall Score
8.1/ 10
🟡 Minor Revision
✅ Layak Diterima Langsung
⚠️ Perlu Peninjauan Lanjutan
Rincian 9 KategoriSkor
Topik & Relevansi9
Struktur Artikel8
Abstract8
Research Gap8
Metodologi7
Data & Statistik8
Discussion8
Conclusion8
References9
Verified by UltimateAI Academic Neural Engine

Metrik Statistik Artikel

0Dilihat
0Diunduh

Negara Asal Pengunjung

Geografi
Indonesia
20 (50.0%)
Malaysia
12 (30.0%)
Singapore
7 (17.5%)
Hal 1 dari 2

Kinerja Jurnal Akademik

Tri-Metric Model
5H-Index
Hirsch (2005)
7i10-Index
Google Scholar
6.5AT-RQS™ RESEARCH QUALITY INDEX
APASIFIC
Definisi & Kerangka Metrik
STANDAR BIBLIOMETRIK
1. H-INDEXJorge E. Hirsch (2005)

"How often is the research cited?"

Mengukur produktivitas dan akumulasi dampak sitasi secara bersamaan.

2. i10-INDEXGoogle Scholar (2011)

"How many works achieved meaningful citation impact?"

Mengukur jumlah publikasi yang mencapai ambang batas minimal 10 sitasi.

3. AT-RQS™ RESEARCH QUALITY INDEXAPASIFIC PROPRIETARY

"How robust is the research quality supporting the evidence?"

Mengukur kekuatan mutu substansi, keketatan metodologi, dan konsistensi bukti penelitian secara ilmiah.

Dasar Rumus Perhitungan:Skala 0–10.0 / 0–100
AT-RQS = 30%(Evidence Quality) + 25%(Methodological Rigor) + 20%(Statistical Strength) + 15%(Research Integrity) + 10%(Scholarly Impact)
Bounded Consistency: AT-RQSfinal = Base Score × [0.85 + 0.15 × (AECI / 100)]
Skala Kategori:9.0–10.0 (Exceptional) • 8.0–8.9 (Strong) • 7.0–7.9 (Good)
Tren Publikasi Bulanan (2026)
13 artikel
2022
29 artikel
2023
49 artikel
2024
75 artikel
2025
107 artikel
2026

Rights

Copyright
Copyright (C) 2026 ASIA PACIFIC ACADEMICIAN

Citation

Muhammad Rahmaddian Syah. (23 A). RECONSTRUCTING THE REGIONAL LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT MECHANISM OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE REGIONAL BUDGET (APBD) IN NORTH SUMATRA: A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE ON LIABILITY AND COMPENSATION. AJLS - Ilmu Hukum & Hak Asasi Manusia, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22065339

Style

Export

Format
ASIA MATRIX MATHEMATICAL SPECIFICATION

Formula & Metodologi Metrik Ilmiah

Spesifikasi perhitungan metrik kanonikal artikel, jurnal, dan penentuan Quartile ASIA Index.

01. AAS — ASIA Article ScoreArticle Level
Main Composite Formula
AASa = min(100.00, max(0.00, (Cprov + Ccit + Cvel + Cnet) × λ(t)))
Cprov (Provenance)Max 40 Pts
Cprov = 40.0 × (PSa / 100)
Ccit (Prestige Citation)Max 35 Pts
Ccit = 35.0 × min(1, ln(1 + Caweighted) / ln(1 + 50.0))
02. ACS — ASIA CiteScore4-Year Window
4-Year Cumulative Citation Impact Formula
ACSy =
Cy-3 + Cy-2 + Cy-1 + CyPy-3 + Py-2 + Py-1 + Py
03. ASJR — ASIA SJRGraph Network
Prestige-Weighted Graph Citation Transfer
ASJRi = ∑j(
ASJRjOj
× Cji × Wij)
04. AIF — ASIA Impact Factor2-Year Window
2-Year Direct Citation Impact Formula
AIFy =
Cy-1 + Cy-2Py-1 + Py-2
05. AI — ASIA INDEXComposite Metric
Multi-Dimensional Weighted Academic Impact Index
AI = WC(CSN) + WS(SJRN) + WI(AIFN) + WQ(QN) + WT(TN)
AI = 0.30(ACSN) + 0.25(ASJRN) + 0.20(AIFN) + 0.15(QN) + 0.10(TN)
06. Percentile & ASIA QuartileTier Categorization
Percentile Rank Formula
Percentilei = 100 ×
Nbelow(AIi)Ntotal − 1
Quartile Mapping Function (Q1–Q4)
Qi =
{
Q1Percentile ≥ 75
Q250 ≤ Percentile < 75
Q325 ≤ Percentile < 50
Q4Percentile < 25

Alur evaluasi ilmiah: Formula → Score → Percentile → Quartile

Publisher Verification
Official Entity

PublisherPT Bernas Sumut Jaya
Legal Entity (Kemenkumham)AHU-0034291.AH.01.01.2026
Klasifikasi KBLI58110 (Penerbitan Buku/Jurnal) & 63121 (Portal Web)
Status:Verified
Evidence: AHU Online
watermark

Publication Lifecycle Passport

Publication Lifecycle
Submitted2026-08-01
AI ScreeningCOMPLETED
Peer ReviewCOMPLETED
Published2026-08-06
Membership Evidence
Status: ACTIVE
Member ID: APS-2026-00125
Member Since: 2026
Expiration: 2027 (Verified)
Professional Certification
Status: Certified
Certification: Research Methodology
Cert Number: CERT-2026-0042
Verification: Verified System
Journal Specifications
Publication Model: Diamond Open Access
APC Charges: Free (Fully Funded)
Peer Review Model: Double Blind Peer Review
Language: English
Editorial Process Evidence
Handling Editor: Editorial Office
Assigned Reviewers: 2 Reviewers
Review Duration: 14 days (Average)
Revision Count: 1 revision
AI Screening Assistant Logs
AI Screening: Completed (PASS)
Similarity Score: 14% Match (Safe)
Conflict of Interest: Not Detected
AI Recommendation: Accept (Ready for Review)
Technical Runtime Diagnostics
ROBOTS.TXT: PASS (Indexed)
SITEMAP.XML: PASS (Dynamic)
OAI ENDPOINT: ACTIVE (/api/oai)
XML SCHEMA: VALID (JATS)
System Platform: IAEP - Integrated Academic Ecosystem Platform

Academic Publication

Journal Indexing Status

Jurnal akademik ASIA resmi didirikan pada tahun 2026. Kami secara aktif mengejar pengindeksan dan registrasi dengan basis data akademik internasional terkemuka dan platform akses terbuka.

APASIFIC INDEX

Indexing Journey Begins

All ASIA journals have officially begun the registration process with international databases. Results and stages are subject to the review schedules of each organization.

Google Scholar

Google Scholar

Active

APASIFIC publications are active and new articles are indexed through Google Scholar.

Crossref

DOI / Crossref

Submitted 2026

APASIFIC DOI registration with Crossref is being processed for permanent publication identification.

ISSN

ISSN Portal

In Queue

The APASIFIC ISSN application has been submitted and is currently in the processing queue.

Zenodo

Zenodo

Active

APASIFIC publication repository providing open storage and DOI records for publications.

OpenAIRE

OpenAIRE

Connected

APASIFIC publications are connected through the Zenodo and OpenAIRE ecosystem for scholarly discovery.

ORCID

ORCID

Integrated

APASIFIC researcher identities and publications are integrated through persistent ORCID researcher identifiers.

SINTA

SINTA

Awaiting ISSN & Akreditasi

The SINTA process is awaiting the journal ISSN and fulfillment of accreditation requirements.

DOAJ

DOAJ

Awaiting ISSN

The DOAJ application will proceed once the ISSN is available and all eligibility requirements are fulfilled.

Scopus

Scopus

Roadmap 2028

Scopus indexing is a development target after editorial requirements and an adequate publication record are fulfilled.

Web of Science

Web of Science

Roadmap 2028

Web of Science is a development target after editorial requirements and an adequate publication record are fulfilled.